I decided to read Me, Earl and the Dying Girl after seeing the trailer for the film, then decided to watch the film first anyway. This was a mistake. Or maybe it wasn’t because I didn’t much enjoy either.

meatdgGreg Gaines is the last master of high school espionage, able to disappear at will into any social environment. He has only one friend, Earl, and together they spend their time making movies, their own incomprehensible versions of Coppola and Herzog cult classics. Until Greg’s mother forces him to rekindle his childhood friendship with Rachel. Rachel has been diagnosed with leukemia—-cue extreme adolescent awkwardness—-but a parental mandate has been issued and must be obeyed. When Rachel stops treatment, Greg and Earl decide the thing to do is to make a film for her, which turns into the Worst Film Ever Made and becomes a turning point in each of their lives. And all at once Greg must abandon invisibility and stand in the spotlight.” GoodReads.

Pros

Greg Gaines is a well-developed character. He’s not perfect, he hates himself a little in that typical teenager way, he’s terrified of life (been there, got the t-shirt) and he’s doing something because he thinks he should when really he wants to run away and hide. I understand that feeling of detachment and fear.

Also, Greg’s friend Earl is the best aspect of the book, giving life lessons and telling Greg exactly what he needs but doesn’t want to hear.

Cons

A barely developed female characters has to die for Greg to grow up and get over his fears. Rachel is dying from cancer, which causes life to throw Greg from practical anonymity to the spotlight, and I found it hard to care that he hates the sudden shift in social placement. I was too annoyed that a woman had to die for a boy to grow up. If I’d been able to get to know Rachel – which I couldn’t as Greg didn’t and he ‘wrote’ the book – I think my opinion of this novel would have been much higher.

Greg Gaines is a well-developed character. I know what you thinking, ‘wait, what? You said this was a pro’ and it is. However, the spot on nature of his characterisation perpetuates the entitled white nerd trope/real-life issue. I’m bored of sympathising with privileged white boys and men at the expense of women.

Me, Earl and the Dying Girl is an easy read, and definitely enjoyable but, unfortunately problematic. I wish I’d been able to enjoy it more.

6
Leave a Reply

avatar
3 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
4 Comment authors
Jenny @ Reading the EndAliceAmanda | musicalpoemNaomi Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Naomi
Guest

I read another review of this book about a year ago that was very negative. I wish I could remember what the main complaint was (and what blog I read it on). I don’t think I’ll be recommending this one to my daughter…

Amanda | musicalpoem
Guest

So I read this when I was on a plane, and maybe that affects my opinion, but I really didn’t like this book. I thought it was just okay at the time, but the more I think about it, the more I realize I dislike it. My issue is that Greg doesn’t seem to develop at all throughout the story! Like, at the end, he’s exactly the same. Um… okay? And yeah, the lack of character development where Rachel was concerned despite her role being fairly pivotal to the crux of the story put a bad taste in my mouth,… Read more »

Jenny @ Reading the End
Guest

God, I am SO bored at being asked to sympathize with men as they meet a lady who changes their lives. It’s just reached a point where — I’ve read enough of those stories. I’m good now. I’m done.